Founding member offer. $270 a year, locked in while you stay a member. After October 31, $407 a year, or $37 a month. You save $137 a year. Includes Navigator, every Learning Path, the Contender and Berean series, cohorts, Unspoken, and every digital file in the store. Renews at $270 a year while you stay a member; cancel anytime online.

Offer ends October 31 at 11:59 PM Eastern.
Founding member offerLock in $270
Back to Read
Study guide · Christian Living & Suffering

What Does It Mean to Preach What You Practice?

Reviewed by Jude 3 Project·10 min read

Tap a Bible reference to read it.Hover over a Bible reference to read it.

Somewhere between a belief you say out loud and the way your week actually goes, there is a gap. Over the next seven days you will name one specific belief your life does not yet back up, read two passages that refuse to let hearing count as doing, and carry out a small practice meant to close that gap by a real amount. You can work through it alone with a notebook, or with a group that meets once before the week begins and once after it ends.

The practice takes its shape from a conversation between Lisa Fields and Bishop Vaughn McLaughlin, the senior pastor and founder of the Potter’s House International Ministries in Jacksonville, on the Jude 3 Project podcast. Asked about people who talk about change without doing it, McLaughlin said:

“I don’t practice what I preach. And I want everybody to know that I really don’t practice what I preach. I preach what I practice. And so I think the power is in the manifestation and doing something about it.”

It is easy to hear that as a line about pastors. Here it works as an instruction about order. Do the thing first. Then let your words report what you did.

Begin with a sentence you already say

Before reading any Scripture, take ten minutes and write down three beliefs you would say out loud without hesitation in an ordinary conversation. Keep them plain. God provides. I have forgiven my sister. My time belongs to God. People who are struggling matter to me.

Now test each one against evidence instead of feeling. If someone could see your calendar, your bank activity, your text messages and the way you spoke about a coworker this past week, what would they conclude you believe? Write one honest line under each statement.

Pick the belief where the evidence is thinnest. That is your gap for the week. Write it in this form: I say ____. My week shows ____.

Three cautions will help you choose well. Pick an ordinary gap, not the most dramatic failure you can recall; ordinary gaps are where most of life happens. Pick something you can act on this week, without needing anyone else to change first. And pick something you are willing to look at for seven days straight.

In a group, nobody has to read their gap aloud. People can share only the general area (money, a relationship, time, speech) or simply say they have written one down. The practice works either way.

Read the mirror before anything else

James is a letter of practical instruction written to scattered believers, and it presses one point harder than almost any other New Testament book: hearing is not the same as doing. Read James 1:22-25 twice, slowly.

James 1:22 sets the command: “But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves.” Then James 1:23-24 gives the picture: “For if any be a hearer of the word, and not a doer, he is like unto a man beholding his natural face in a glass: For he beholdeth himself, and goeth his way, and straightway forgetteth what manner of man he was.”

A “glass” in KJV English is a mirror. Notice what goes wrong in the picture. The man does look. He sees himself accurately. The failure comes after, when he walks away and forgets. James 1:25 describes the other person: “But whoso looketh into the perfect law of liberty, and continueth therein, he being not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, this man shall be blessed in his deed.”

Underline where the blessing lands in that verse. It lands “in his deed.” Then read 1 John 3:18: “My little children, let us not love in word, neither in tongue; but in deed and in truth.”

One interpretive note before you go on. James 2:17 says, “Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.” James is not teaching that works earn salvation. Read Ephesians 2:8-9 alongside it: “For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast.” Then Ephesians 2:10: “For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.” Grace comes first, and the good works follow as the walk it produces. Many Christian interpreters read James as describing the difference between a living faith and a bare profession. The gap you wrote down is not a verdict on whether you belong to God. It marks a place your faith has not yet reached your hands.

  1. In James’s mirror picture, the looking is accurate and the forgetting is the problem. What would “continueth therein” look like, concretely, for the gap you wrote down?
  2. John pairs “deed” with “truth” and “word” with “tongue.” What does that pairing suggest about words that run ahead of what a person has done?

What McLaughlin changes about the order

The context of McLaughlin’s line matters. Lisa Fields had named a specific habit: “we can be social media advocates and not be actually doing the work.” McLaughlin answered by flipping the familiar saying. In the usual version, your words set the standard and your life tries to catch up. In his version, your life is the source and your words are the report.

He connects this to the relationship between belief and action, which he summarizes as “what we know and what we do.” The danger, in his words, is when “if what we know doesn’t affect what we do,” and he points to Daniel 11:32: “And such as do wickedly against the covenant shall he corrupt by flatteries: but the people that do know their God shall be strong, and do exploits.” Daniel 11 is prophetic writing that describes faithful people standing firm while others are corrupted. McLaughlin draws an application from it: “So what we need to be doing, the exploits that we need to be performing comes out of our knowledge of God.”

Then he gives a set of questions he uses on himself. They are the most usable part of the conversation for this week:

“Who am I helping? Who am I enhancing? What am I doing? How does the gospel impact lives? How do I meet the felt needs of people?”

Notice the direction of those questions. They do not ask whether you feel consistent. They ask whether anyone is better off. Go back to your gap and see whether the action you are considering touches another person. If your gap is I say I trust God with money, an action that only changes how often you check your balance stays inside you. An action that gives something specific to someone who needs it moves outward. Some gaps are inward by nature, such as prayer, and that is fine. But if an outward version exists, try it.

The week

Day 1. Write your gap as one sentence and one action. Name when and where you will do the action, and keep it small enough to finish. I say I have forgiven my sister. On Wednesday evening I will call her and ask about her week, with no agenda.

Before you commit, check the action three ways. First, ask whether you are trying to earn something. McLaughlin describes being saved at 26, alone in his living room, before he had heard a sermon, and he says of what came after, “I do what I do now, empowered by the gospel.” If your action feels like a payment to God, rewrite it as a response. Second, ask who you hope will notice. Matthew 6:1 warns: “Take heed that ye do not your alms before men, to be seen of them: otherwise ye have no reward of your Father which is in heaven.” McLaughlin admits the pull himself: “It’s difficult for me, even right now sitting here talking about what we do.” That is why you will tell no one about the action until Day 7. Third, ask how close to home it is. McLaughlin says, “You have to remain faithful to your immediate surrounding, your own little Jerusalem. Take care of it first before you try to go to the ends of the world and make a name for yourself.” Choose people who already know you and cannot be impressed by a reputation.

Finally, choose one trusted person to talk with on Day 7. McLaughlin describes answering to an eldership and to other pastors and leaders, and says, “And that’s why I find my safety.” You need at least one person close enough to notice drift.

  1. Days 2 and 3. Do the action, or the first part of it. Each night, write one line answering one of McLaughlin’s questions. Start with Who am I helping? If the honest answer is nobody, write that, and write what got in the way: time, fear, cost or forgetting.
  2. Day 4. Reread James 1:23-25. Ask whether you have been the man who looks and walks away. If the action was too large, shrink it. Adjusting is not quitting.
  3. Days 5 and 6. Continue. Rotate the nightly question: What am I doing? then How do I meet the felt needs of people? Notice whether the questions are getting easier to answer or harder.
  4. Day 7. Now you may speak. Tell your trusted person what you did and why. Then rewrite your opening sentence so that it says only what is true today: I say ____, and this week I ____.

When the group meets again

Start the second meeting with what people did, not how they felt about it, and let anyone pass.

  1. On Day 7 you spoke about something you had already done. What was different about talking that way, compared with how you usually talk about your faith?
  2. Which of McLaughlin’s questions was hardest to answer honestly this week, and what made it hard?
  3. Staying silent until Day 7 was meant to guard against doing things to be seen. Did the silence help you, or did it make drifting easier? What would you change next time?
  4. What evidence would show you, a month from now, that the gap actually closed, rather than that you had one good week?

Some people will discover during the week that their gap is larger than a seven-day practice can hold: a hidden pattern they cannot break, a relationship involving harm, a struggle with their mind or body. Do not work that through in front of the group. Talk with the person privately and help them connect with a pastor or a trained counselor. Seeking that kind of help is not a failure of faith.

Day eight

Go back to the page where you first tested your three beliefs against your calendar and your bank activity. When you started, you may have assumed you knew why the gap was there. Now read your seven nightly lines and look for the pattern they actually show. Was it fear of what the action would cost? Not enough time? An action that was too large? Or forgetting, like the man who walks away from the mirror? Write down which one fits your lines, and whether it is the reason you would have guessed on Day 1.

McLaughlin describes the real arena of faith this way: “It’s life after the benediction.” The second-weakest belief from your first page is still there, waiting for its own week.